Log in

Fetkenhier’s unceremonious departure from Cactus remains baffling

Posted 1/8/18

A blog by Richard Smith

West Valley Preps

Since I learned of Cactus coach Larry Fetkenhier’s (forced) resignation — like many of you did — during the middle of a holiday vacation, I’ve …

You must be a member to read this story.

Join our family of readers for as little as $5 per month and support local, unbiased journalism.


Already have an account? Log in to continue.

Current print subscribers can create a free account by clicking here

Otherwise, follow the link below to join.

To Our Valued Readers –

Visitors to our website will be limited to five stories per month unless they opt to subscribe. The five stories do not include our exclusive content written by our journalists.

For $6.99, less than 20 cents a day, digital subscribers will receive unlimited access to YourValley.net, including exclusive content from our newsroom and access to our Daily Independent e-edition.

Our commitment to balanced, fair reporting and local coverage provides insight and perspective not found anywhere else.

Your financial commitment will help to preserve the kind of honest journalism produced by our reporters and editors. We trust you agree that independent journalism is an essential component of our democracy. Please click here to subscribe.

Sincerely,
Charlene Bisson, Publisher, Independent Newsmedia

Please log in to continue

Log in
I am anchor

Fetkenhier’s unceremonious departure from Cactus remains baffling

Posted
A blog by Richard Smith West Valley Preps

Since I learned of Cactus coach Larry Fetkenhier’s (forced) resignation — like many of you did — during the middle of a holiday vacation, I’ve been waiting for the other shoe to drop.

Waiting for that piece of information, or even informed speculation, that causes me to think, ‘Oh, okay, that’s why they wanted to part ways.’ Writing this nine days after Fetkenhier announced his resignation Dec. 27 that smoking gun — or even a trail to the smoking gun — eludes me.

Judging from the outpouring of shock, anger, tributes and testimonials of hundreds of current and former players, Cobra parents, coaching peers and people with no obvious ties to the program, this is the prevailing sentiment.

It is hard to wrap the mind around what, to this point, appears to be a fairly simple disagreement with some members of the school’s administration that led to a coach with 34 years invested in the Glendale school and 330 wins leaving days after the team banquet and no previous indication that he was close to done.

Were the misgivings of school leadership about how the program was run severe enough to force a change? Or — even harder to believe — do principal Kristi Hammer and athletic director Chad Doyle believe the coach had lost a step, though most schools would tout 33 wins in the last four years (at Cactus, this is a dry period).

Do they really think one of the most consistently successful football programs in the history of the state needs to go in a different direction?

That’s what we are led to believe from what has been released thus far, which is largely one statement on the afternoon of Dec. 27, which read:

"Last Friday at 11:00 the Cactus Administration informed me they want to take the program in a different direction. I have resigned my position as the Head Varsity Football Coach at Cactus High School today, December, 27, 2017 - Larry Fetkenhier.

Minutes later, it was followed by a second statement: "Coach wants to thank all players and parents for their great support of the program and him for these many years."

Literally hundreds of people have commented on the decision since, but perhaps the most succinct was from Ty Lorts on Twitter, who tweeted: "Unless something illegal was happening, he earned the right to say when he leaves and now."

Instead it appears Fetkenhier was shown the door in the second most ignominious way possible — the first being an outright firing.

The last Friday referred to in the letter is Dec. 22, days after the season-ending banquet and the last day of school for teachers. Winter break had begun for students and teachers, including Fetkenhier, were catching up on paperwork.

"We didn’t have kids that Friday and most people had left campus but I was still working. I got a call and the athletic director discussed with me that they wanted to go in a different direction. And that was it. It was kind of a tough few days. ... My family and I will move forward from this," Fetkenhier said during an Dec. 30 interview with Kevin McCabe on AZPreps Live on Arizona Sports 98.7 FM.

In recent years I’ve covered city government and the equivalent of this move would be a mayor disliking a beloved city manager with more than 30 years on the job, but knowing an outright firing during a City Council meeting would lead to an immediate public outcry.

Instead, the mayor sits back and takes some time to line up the votes. A special meeting is called at 4 p.m. Friday and the manager is voted out with only a terse public statement, in the hopes that the press coverage will be muted and the city manager’s supporters will cool their anger after a weekend.

Winter break is quite a long weekend.

As the high school sports sage McCabe summarized in his lead-in to the interview, "We kicked a legend to the curb."

Cactus head coach Larry Fetkenhier, left, gives instruction to his players during practice on Aug. 10, 2017, at Cactus High School in Glendale. [Jacob Stanek/West Valley Preps][/caption]

No one, not his staunchest defenders nor the man himself, would call Larry Fetkenhier a saint. His critical eye and sometimes brutal brand of honesty extended to the man in the mirror.

Interviewing him in the summer of 2015 following successful surgery late in the 2014 to remove cancer confined to his kidney, he was genuinely touched by the similar outpouring of prayers, reflections and well wishes from the wide net "of people whose lives. In the next breath, he questioned whether he was deserving of it.

"It made me realize I haven’t always been the best person," Fetkenhier said at the time.

And no profile of the legend would be complete without a description of his crusty exterior. I later learned he was from near Flint, Michigan and arrived at Cactus after being laid off as a teacher and coach and having to work in fleet sales. That explains a lot.

Honestly, for the first year-and-a-half covering local prep sports, I loathed dealing with the man. And he likely thought of me as that pain in the ass reporter that never shows up on time for interviews — that later point hasn’t changed.

Sometime during the 2009 season I asked him a more introspective question than usual and he stopped the interview, looked at me and said, "you know, that’s a really good question."

Our professional relationship began to improve from there, and during the course of that 2009 state title drive and a subsequent 2010 preseason interview with the three pillars of Peoria Unified School District football, Fetkenhier, Peoria’s Doug Clapp and Centennial’s Richard Taylor, I learned more about the true depth of the man.

Fetkenhier loved to win — he called a 7-3 season in 2012 unacceptable — but he stayed at Cactus for bigger reasons. He wanted to mold — forge may be the better word — young men into successful adults that would be a credit to their community.

Players and coaches worked hard constantly, during the season and in preparation for the next one. In spring, it seemed like the core of Cactus football was always outside or in the weight room, working on their games or their strength and conditioning.

But you got the sense he could care less about the youth football scene or what players in it would come to Cactus. His relationships with players started when they stepped on campus and his program was not going to bend to the talent of a star or a kid who transferred in.

Yes it was old-school and sometimes uncompromising to a fault. But it was refreshing — a throwback to the football of the 80s and 90s where words like recruiting, transfer and open enrollment were the exception, not the rule. When parents didn’t use schools like chess pieces in effort to maximize their kid’s profile or brazenly shop for schools and scholarships.

Instead, he coached football and life lessons to those willing to receive them. While things changed to the point where I can honestly say Fetkenhier became my favorite interview for his candor, seeming absence of coach-speak and view of the big picture, one thing never changed.

I needed to interview those kids before or after practice, because practice was planned with precision and purpose. The Cactus practices I witnessed where the most intense I have seen, a blur of motion designed to simulate game tempo and decision making at that speed.

Mistakes would be pointed out, loudly, by the coach with the unsparing eye. The language would turn a darker shade of blue than the Cobras’ helmets.

Yet this was another way to prepare kids beyond football. In the adult world, people will let you know when you’ve screwed up, and they won’t be nice about it. If you learn from them and get better, however, things will improve.

Most of all, Fetkenhier preached that consistent hard work was the key to success on and off the field. That at some point, a boy has to accept the responsibility of becoming a man, and having that work ethic will see him through his troubles and lift up those around him.

Those lessons and that relentless work didn’t always resonate with high school kids, particularly in the 21st Century. Cactus rosters always seemed to shrink between August and October of recent years as a generation raised with a much softer ethos collided with the Cobra Tradition.

But former players, with the benefit of time spent in the real world, came to revere what Fetkenhier did for them.

Their joy was more in seeing their old coach win the big one than in their old school. By this point, he was the essence of Cobra football.

At the same time, I never saw a coach attract so many former players — from such a wide range of graduating classes — to big games. And I never witnessed a program celebrate alums that went on to blue-collar, professional, military and first responder careers every bit as much as those that played college ball.

The coach worked just as hard, serving as his own offensive coordinator all 34 years, and tweaking his scheme to best fit his personnel in nearly all of those seasons.

Fetkenhier also became a spokesman for his peers and a leading voice of the Arizona Football Coaches Association on several grievances with the AIA, including the bizarre setup for 2011 and 2012 without regions and with a schedule largely determined by computers.

Larry Fetkenhier was the first to let the greater Arizona high school football community know the severity of former Ironwood coach Chuck Esquivel’s cancer, spoke at his Ironwood sports hall of fame induction and was on hand for the Ironwood field dedication in Esquivel’s name just last month.

After a decade where Fetkenhier’s Cobras and Doug Clapp’s Peoria Panthers went at each other like the Hattfields and McCoys on and off the field, their relationship began to thaw. By the time Clapp had to resign amid allegations (and charges of) misusing football program funds in early 2012, Fetkenhier’s was one of his closest friends in the profession.

He developed an admiration — and friendship with Peoria coach Will Babb, the quarterback of those Peoria teams that bedeviled his early Cobras powerhouses. Partially, that was due to the more friendly nature of the grand rivalry after its revival in 2007. But he also saw a kindred spirit in a football landscape that had strayed far from its roots, and would speak of Babb’s decency whenever the rival coach came under fire.

I remember him talking to then-Paradise Valley (and now ASU assistant) Donnie Yantis asking if he wanted red pants donated by the Arizona Cardinals that the Cobras had no use for.

Perhaps that is why many of the loudest outraged voiced on social media since Fetkenhier was forced out belong to current and former coaches.

"I think the older I get, the more mortal I am. You learn to care about other people more. My coaching peers, you see people get beat up (by outside pressure from parents, fans and the media) and it really bothers me. You see stuff like that happen to people you know, and that hurts. Do you know how much we make a year? I may still be a grouchy old grump, but it bothers me. I guess I have more passion for my peers," Fetkenhier said in that 2010 interview.

A little more than seven years later something like that happened to him, only from within that school.

In more than three decades, Larry Fetkenhier built one or Arizona’s best football traditions at a working class Glendale school surrounded more by shops and restaurants than homes. He rarely had large numbers or big money behind his program and never took shortcuts.

He did a brief interview Dec. 29 with Richard Obert of AZCentral, stating he wanted to take the high road and was not done coaching. But for many of those whose lives he impacted, including me, the question remains.

Is there a need for a "different direction?" I would love to know why?

Hammer and Doyle and whomever else thought it was time do not answer a community newspaper writer.

But they’ll need to speak up soon, because the letters to them, acting PUSD Superintendent Steve Savoy and district HR director Carter Davidson.

I’m guessing some people in the district leadership will demand more concrete answers, and soon.