Log in
Opinion

Negative signs and questionable finances in Scottsdale race

OPINION — Barry Graham, Michelle Ugenti-Rita and Bob Littlefield have complained for months about negative signs opposing their campaigns for city council. However, the Better Together PAC hasn’t …
Brian and Julie Cieniawski
Opinion

The Scottsdale Unified bond provides vital infrastructure

OPINION — We proudly support the 2025 Scottsdale Unified School District bond plan because it directly funds essential infrastructure, such as modernizing schools, technology servers, plumbing and …
Opinion

Zubia’s stance on Scottsdale’s Farmers’ Market

OPINION — I agree the farmers’ market’s new location is pretty terrific. For the vendors and the buyers. But I was there for the initiation of the Farmers’ Market in Old Town years …
Amy Carney
Opinion

Why experience matters in the Scottsdale school board election

OPINION — Experience matters when making decisions that shape the future of our schools. But not all experience is the same. I'm a mother of six children, all educated in Scottsdale Unified …
Maria Wojtczak
Opinion

Beyond the driving test: Helping Arizona teens become safer drivers

OPINION — Getting a driver’s license means freedom for teenagers, but for parents, it can bring fear and anxiety. In 2024, 2,320 teen drivers ages 15 to 18 died in auto crashes and more than 80,000 were injured.

Question of the Week: Does your family participate in Halloween traditions and fun?

There was a time when nothing signaled the onset of autumn like Halloween, the annual cultural celebration observed on Oct. 31, which features trick-or-treating, wearing costumes and carving …
Opinion

Graham not the right candidate for Scottsdale

OPINION — Barry Graham’s message and his money don’t add up He wants us to believe he is Scottsdale’s anti-development candidate. His campaign finances tell a different story. During his 2022 …
Opinion

Why I’m supporting Raoul Zubia for Scottsdale council

OPINION — For decades, I ran Don & Charlie’s Steakhouse on a simple principle: a good night happens when everybody in the building pulls in the same direction. The kitchen, the …
Opinion

Scottsdale voters deserve clarity on lingering questions

OPINION — Sexual harassment allegations should never be dismissed as political theater. They deserve serious attention, fair scrutiny and accountability, no matter who is involved. That standard …
Opinion

South Scottsdale is still Scottsdale

OPINION — Raoul Zubia has called Scottsdale home his entire life. He was raised here, educated here, and today lives in the same South Scottsdale home where he grew up, having returned to care for …
Erica Grabinski, D.O.
Opinion

Bridging the gap between breast cancer awareness and action

OPINION — New American Cancer Society research reveals a gap between breast-cancer awareness and action that can save lives. In Arizona, approximately 900 women died from breast cancer in 2024, …
Take the Civility Pledge

Civility Checklist

How to engage in respectful, honest & civil dialogue about public issues.

Checkmark Take the high road.  Respond to the topic — not the person. Refrain from demonizing others for their opinions. Assume those you disagree with are, like you, genuinely interested in improving the community.

Checkmark Be respectful. Bullying, public humiliation, insults, name-calling, harassment, and threats directed at another person — or that person's race, gender, religion, ethnicity, etc. — have no place in civil discussions. Find ways to respectfully disagree without questioning someone's character or motives.

Checkmark Be truthful. Base your opinions/arguments on facts. Value honesty. Make only accurate statements when making your point and avoid exaggeration and stereotypes. When appropriate, cite your sources of information that others may question. 

Checkmark Don't misrepresent. Always identify your opinions as opinions (not stating opinions as facts). Never misrepresent the views of others or falsely claim your opinions represent someone else. If quoting the words of others, identify and credit the source.

Checkmark Listen  & learn. It's both polite and respectful to listen to those we disagree with (as well as those we support) and be genuine in our attempts to understand their point of view. Expand your mind by thoughtfully seeking out views that don't agree with your own.

CheckmarkLook for common ground. When disagreeing with others, look for even small areas of agreement — which can be the gateway to working together for the greater good.

Checkmark Respect privacy. Keep private things private — whether it involves your own information or those with whom you disagree. Revealing private information about someone else is rude, unethical, potentially harmful and, in many cases, illegal.

Checkmark Set a good example. Practice civil behavior online as well as in public and in your interaction with others. Encourage others to practice these civil behaviors. And it's OK to challenge disrespectful behavior — but be courteous, respectful and helpful in your approach.

Now that you've read the checklist, take the Civility Pledge. 

Our civility pledge member community
Your Community Your Voice
Photo Caption

Scottsdale deserves council member above suspicion

OPINION — Public office runs on trust. Barry Graham has spent that trust down to almost nothing. Graham is at the center of an Attorney General investigation into whether Scottsdale’s …
Photo Caption

Scottsdale election and opinion pieces

OPINION — Christian Serena’s recent opinion piece urged voters to back Barry Graham and Michelle Ugenti-Rita. It was presented as the view of a former planning commissioner and concerned …
Jason Reed

Fighting hunger also means prioritizing nutrition

OPINION — When most people think about hunger, they picture an empty pantry or fridge. Yet, for families struggling to make ends meet, the challenge is often more complicated than simply having enough food to eat.
Photo Caption

Scottsdale’s future depends on getting water, growth right

OPINION — I'm proud to be a Scottsdale resident. I attended our schools, graduated from Coronado, and now attend Scottsdale Community College. My family moved to Scottsdale because of its promise …
Gary Shapiro

That magical Scottsdale Unified address

OPINION — As a Scottsdale Realtor for the past 55 years, I've learned the three most important things about real estate are: location, location and location. In Scottsdale's case, it relates to the …
Raoul Zubia

Candidate Raoul Zubia responds to Scottsdale letter

OPINION — Christian Serena’s op-ed is a list of things I didn’t do. I didn’t write SB 1543, lobby for it, or vote on it. Every contribution to my campaign is publicly disclosed, and no …
Photo Caption

Graham and Ugenti-Rita will protect Scottsdale’s water

OPINION — Scottsdale stands alone as a leader of water conservation, recycling and storage. We have reused and recharged what we have for more than 20 years. This council is making record water …
Chad Michael

Arizona business leaders: Skip the boring icebreakers at company functions

OPINION — Phoenix is having a moment as a meeting destination, recently ranking No. 4 in U.S. News & World Report’s inaugural list of the nation’s best conference cities. But filling a ballroom is only half the job. With Gallup reporting that 51% of remote-capable U.S. employees work in hybrid roles, the more important question is what happens once everyone gets together?
Photo Caption

What has become of the Republican party?

OPINION — Cancer spreads, as do many diseases, and certainly this is the case with the Republican party. The days when integrity went along with conservative values is gone with Trump. Now, you …
Photo Caption

Graham’s history with Scottsdale’s ethics code

OPINION — As a Scottsdale resident since 1985, I had the honor to serve on the Charter Review Task Force in 2009 and the Citizens Code of Ethics Task Force in 2005-06. In 2006, the city council …
Photo Caption

Follow the money in Scottsdale’s council election

OPINION — I served on Scottsdale's Planning Commission when Axon asked to approve roughly 1,900 apartments at Hayden and the Loop 101. I read every page of the plans. I listened to the residents. …
Photo Caption

Paper water should equal wet water

OPINION — I have written 100 essays about Arizona water, runaway growth, sprawl, wildcat development, the Colorado River and the relentless destruction of the desert we keep claiming we want to …
Denny Brown  and Melinda Gulick

Scottsdale bond supports our schools’ future

OPINION — As long-time champions of the Scottsdale Unified School District and co-chairs of Yes to Children, we urge you to join us in voting yes on the SUSD bond. A yes vote invests in our …
Jeanne Beasley

Elections, and school closures in Scottsdale, have consequences

OPINION — Elections have consequences. Recently, Scottsdale families saw just how significant those consequences can be when the governing board voted 3-2 to close two more neighborhood schools. …
Photo Caption

Question of the Week: Should the Pentagon livestream the execution of former U.S. Army Maj. Nidal Hasan?

Former Army Medical Corps psychiatrist Nidal Hasan is scheduled to be executed by firing squad Dec. 3 at Fort Hood, Texas, for the 2009 mass shooting that claimed the lives of 13 soldiers and wounded …
TR Harry

Crossroads: Where does America go from here?

OPINION — The liberal American democracy we all grew up in is under severe strain. The America of strong middle class, stable jobs, predictable two big-tent party politics and national confidence has been seriously compromised. The economic and political choices of the past 40-plus years reshaped American life, and those choices are now being questioned.
Lara Palles

Heartbroken about Laguna, still supporting Scottsdale Unified bond

OPINION — I am heartbroken about Laguna, and I will still vote yes on the SUSD bond. My family spent 12 years at Laguna. Its educators helped my children thrive. I fought to keep it open. My …
Photo Caption

Governor Hobbs successes on securing the border

OPINION — Securing Arizona’s border matters and requires coordination among federal, state, county, Tribal and local law enforcement. This takes collaborative leadership and Governor Katie …
Photo Caption

Scottsdale’s ever-increasing surveillance state

OPINION — Kudos to Scottsdale Mayor Lisa Borowsky for questioning whether Flock cameras violate our constitutional guarantee to the right of privacy as described in the Fourth Amendment. I think we …
Photo Caption

I vote early, but not by mail

OPINION — I have been voting by mail since Arizona instituted it. Before that, most of my voting was by mail because I was first active-duty Air Force, then a spouse and voting absentee. I have …
Jan Dubauskas

Your safety is why I support Graham and Ugenti-Rita for Scottsdale

OPINION — Scottsdale’s high quality of life starts with its residents feeling safe in their neighborhoods and around their community. It’s the foundation of everything else we value; strong …
Raoul Zubia

Vote for Zubia in Scottsdale, a leader who listens

OPINION — Scottsdale is a community we share and a future we shape together. I am deeply concerned about the direction of our city council. Cutting vital water resources and trading solutions for …
Photo Caption

Vote to support strong education in Scottsdale Unified and beyond

OPINION — There have been a few opinions posted in the PV independent lamenting the closure of neighborhood public schools. I sympathize. However, I don’t understand blaming school boards for …
Photo Caption

Arizona voters deserve a gubernatorial debate

OPINION — Why are we not insisting that Governor Katie Hobbs publicly debate her opponents before the November election? Arizonans, we live in the home of the Wild West. Questioning authority, …
Photo Caption

Ugenti-Rita, Graham right for Scottsdale

OPINION — We long-time Scottsdale residents chose to make the city our home. Simply being born here fails to make a candidate qualified. Years of drought and Colorado River cuts have made …
Jennifer Johnson

The experience Scottsdale schools need

OPINION — I am Jennifer Johnson,  a candidate for the SUSD Governing Board. As a native Arizonan, educator, parent and community member, I will bring proven leadership to the SUSD governing …
Photo Caption

No better time for Scottsdale to eliminate sales tax on food

OPINION — Recently, the Independent reported on Scottsdale’s large revenue increases. Normally, such good fortune would be greeted with applause and high-fives for everyone that made it …
Kavein Maxwell.

Scottsdale unified bond is a need, not a want

OPINION — I'm voting yes on the Scottsdale Unified School District bond, and I hope you'll join me. Through my work on SUSD's Spark Committee, I've seen how much our district is planning for …
Photo Caption

Scottsdale Councilman Graham’s endorsement, record, raise concerns

OPINION — Scottsdale Councilman Barry Graham has endorsed Alexander Kolodin for Arizona Secretary of State. Voters should look past the campaign shorthand and at what that endorsement and …
Photo Caption

Question of the Week: Are you voting by mail this year or going to the polls Nov. 3?

There has been plenty of bluster about mail-in voting, some of the negative coming from President Trump  — who votes by mail himself. Do you believe in the integrity of voting by mail through …
Taylor Bell

Closures or not, vote yes on Scottsdale Unified bond

OPINION — I'm a Scottsdale Unified dad with three kids in the district. I spent countless hours as PTO president at Redfield Elementary, and I still have a child there. Redfield will likely be …
Photo Caption

Scottsdale election a choice between residents and special interests

OPINION — A longtime concern in Scottsdale has been the tight grip special interests hold on city hall. Think about what still frustrates you: unwanted high-density apartments, strain on water …
Photo Caption

Scottsdale Unified board election matters more than you think

OPINION — You don’t need to have a child currently in a Scottsdale Unified classroom to care about who sits on our school board. As taxpayers, we certainly need to pay attention. Our public …
Photo Caption

Chamber supports Scottsdale Unified bond measure

OPINION — On behalf of the Scottsdale Area Chamber of Commerce, I am writing to express our strong support for the Scottsdale Unified School District's $375 million bond measure on the Nov. 3 …
Photo Caption

Vote no on Scottsdale Unified bond request

OPINION — SUSD wasted much of its two prior bonds ($347 million - 2010, 2016) renovating/rebuilding schools it has since closed and anticipates closing. Meanwhile, SUSD continues losing enrollment, …
Photo Caption

We know where Andy Biggs really stands

OPINION — Andy Biggs wants Arizonans to forget what he did after the 2020 election. We shouldn't, and I for certain have not. The organizer of the Jan. 6 rally said Biggs helped come up with …
Julie Kwatra, MD, and Athena Salman

Arizona voters protected abortion rights, Washington can still threaten women’s health

OPINION — In 2024, nearly two million Arizonans voted for Proposition 139, amending our state Constitution to protect the fundamental right to abortion. It passed with nearly 62 percent of the …
Photo Caption

Scottsdale’s Flock discussion should be in a regular meeting

OPINION — At the Sept. 22 city council meeting, Mayor Borowsky moved to agendize a decision on the controversial Flock cameras. She said it was time for council to take a clear stand for or against …
Photo Caption

Support Scottsdale Unified improvements with a yes vote

OPINION — As the recently retired principal of Desert Mountain High School, I feel very strongly about voting yes for the special bond election. The infrastructure investment will allow the …

A needed investment in Scottsdale Unified

OPINION — Join me in supporting our students by voting yes on the Scottsdale Unified School District capital bond. Across our region, strong public schools are the foundation of strong …