Tactically, Arizona Democrats would be wise to keep in mind the referendum threat
Posted
Robert Robb
Submitted photo/Robert Robb
If Hobbs and legislative Democrats adopt a comprehensive measure along the lines of the previous initiative, it would likely be subjected to a successful referendum drive. That would mean that the voucher program would continue as it is, without reform, until at least November 2028. And there would be a highly expensive ballot measure campaign fight in 2028, draining resources Democrats might prefer to be spent elsewhere, such as preserving their legislative majorities.”
OPINION — Gov. Katie Hobbs and the incoming Democratic legislative majority have made it clear that an early and high priority will be reform of the Empowerment Scholarship Account program.
They might not give much credit to an analysis by a voucher supporter, even one who has previously advocated for reforms of the program. But perhaps readers will be interested, so here goes anyway.
Democrats seem to believe that they have a blank political canvass for reforms, given their overwhelming majorities in both chambers of the Legislature. That, however, is a serious misreading of the political landscape.
In addition to local advocates, there are well-heeled national organizations supportive of school choice, particularly vouchers to attend private schools.
Under Arizona’s Constitution, there is the referendum power. Voters can suspend a law passed by the Legislature and signed by the governor, in whole or in part. The referred law goes on the ballot at the next general election, for the entire electorate to decide its fate.
Although there is a shorter period of time to gather signatures, the required number for a referendum is half that for a statutory initiative, or a voter-proposed law, and a third that of a constitutional initiative. It’s 5% of the number of voters who cast ballots in the most recent gubernatorial election.
After the 2026 election, the number of required signatures for a referendum would be around 130,000. That’s something, politically, that money could buy.
Democrats are talking about making their starting point the proposed voucher reform initiative that came up short of verified signatures for the 2026 election. That’s a mistake substantively, as discussed anon. It’s also a mistake tactically, given the referendum threat.
If Hobbs and legislative Democrats adopt a comprehensive measure along the lines of the previous initiative, it would likely be subjected to a successful referendum drive. That would mean that the voucher program would continue as it is, without reform, until at least November 2028. And there would be a highly expensive ballot measure campaign fight in 2028, draining resources Democrats might prefer to be spent elsewhere, such as preserving their legislative majorities.
A tactically smart strategy for Democrats in light of the referendum threat would be to enact reforms piecemeal, rather than in a single comprehensive package. Not all reform ideas have the same referendum threat risk.
Importantly, a reform that has a much lower risk profile is one that actually addresses the abuses of the program that have given it the taint of scandal.
Those abuses aren’t coming from tuition reimbursements for attending private schools. They are coming from the elements of the program for homeschoolers.
The initiative was a bait-and-switch operation. It attempted to use public outrage over the abuses as cover to impose unrelated regulations on private schools and adopt an income cap for the program. The initiative included no actual reforms of the program for homeschoolers.
The design of the program for homeschoolers is flawed. Parents decide what they want to spend and then submit a claim to the state. The volume of such requests overwhelms the ability of the state to process or police them. So, scammers can get away, at least initially, with wildly inappropriate purchases.
I’ve advocated that, instead, the state pre-approve grade-level resources that it is willing to pay for and limit homeschoolers to the pre-approved list, with an exception for special ed kids. No approval delays, no scandals.
I don’t think a reform, this or some other, that truly addressed the abuses that have surfaced in the program for homeschoolers would face a referendum threat, if enacted as a stand-alone measure. My reform would be the most far-reaching. Homeschoolers wouldn’t like being limited to a pre-approved list of resources. They are an important grassroots constituency for Republicans. However, I doubt that they have the political heft to mount a successful referendum drive on their own. And I don’t think a reform strictly addressing the abuses that have arisen in the program for homeschoolers would trigger action by the national school choice organizations. The existing program is pretty indefensible.
With respect to private schools, I think it would be appropriate to require voucher students to take the same achievement tests as public school pupils, with results comparably reported. If enacted as a stand-alone measure, I doubt that would trigger a referendum. I suspect that the results would end up being an effective marketing tool for the private schools.
The initiative would have required private schools accepting voucher students to register and pay a fee to the state every year. It also would have given the state regulatory oversight over private school facilities and personnel.
This, I would bet, would trigger a referendum. The overwhelming majority of private schools in Arizona are located in and administered by churches. Most of these schools have been in the business of educating children for generations. There is utterly no justification for subjecting them to a state regulatory regimen that necessarily would intrude upon internal church matters and operations.
Democrats want to impose a family income cap on eligibility. Hobbs has proposed a ceiling of $250,000. The initiative had it at $150,000.
I don’t know whether an income cap, as a stand-alone measure, would trigger a referendum. The national school choice organizations would hate it. But I suspect it would poll extremely well. Moreover, if approved at an election, it would be voter-protected under Arizona’s Constitution. Meaning that a future GOP Legislature probably couldn’t increase or eliminate it, as it could if the cap remained just something passed by a Democratic Legislature.
I’m opposed to an income cap. However, if there is to be one, it should be more thoughtfully constructed than that proposed by either Hobbs or the initiative.
Both had a hard cap. One dollar under the cap, and the family could take full advantage of the voucher program. One dollar over, and the family is cut off from the program entirely. Instead, there should be a phase-out spectrum.
Consider the $150,000 initiative cap and a family making $149,000 with two kids in private school receiving $15,000 in tuition reimbursements. If the family were to get a $2,000 raise, it would actually be close to $15,000 poorer. Taking into account federal and state income taxes, the family would actually need a raise to around $180,000 to be meaningfully ahead.
It’s bad policy to create such disincentives for families to make an additional buck. Federal welfare programs are rife with such perverse marginal effects. The state’s ESA program should avoid them.
Hobbs and legislative Democrats have a lot of policy choices to make regarding ESA reform. But they also have to decide the extent to which they want to have reforms up and operational, versus just setting up a blowout ballot measure campaign fight for 2028.
Retired Arizona journalist Robert Robb opines about politics and public policy. Reach him at robtrobb@gmail.com. Please submit comments at yourvalley.net/letters or email them to azopinions@iniusa.org. We are committed to publishing a wide variety of reader opinions, as long as they meet our Civility Guidelines.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here