Log in
Opinion

The biggest freeloader in SNL’s ‘Sister’ skit isn’t who you think

Caregiver: Flawed Medicare system puts undue burden on families of Americans with dementia

Posted

OPINION — In a now-viral “Saturday Night Live” sketch, comedian JohnMulaney plays a man whose aging father suddenly needs care at home. He discovers a miraculous eldercare service: his sister. She immediately flies in and starts tending to all the father’s needs … while the brother resumes doing whatever he likes.

Yes, he’s a freeloader. However, there’s an even bigger freeloader off-screen: America’s healthcare system that runs on the backs of millions of unpaid family caregivers.

As we see commentaries celebrating November as National Family Caregivers Month, it’s time to stop paying lip service to “supporting caregivers” and shine a light on how our flawed Medicare system overlooks caregiving. Yes, Medicare pays for qualifying, intermittent “skilled care” at home, such as after discharge from the hospital following a major surgery. However, Medicare excludes what it calls “custodial care,”  such as bathing, dressing, help with meals — in circumstances when that is the only help needed. 

Unfortunately, that’s the biggest need for millions of older Americans. Most people don’t realize Medicare doesn’t cover it until it happens to them. And then, someone ends up eventually supplying those hours, usually a middle-age daughter.

Dementia exposes the cruelty of this distinction between “skilled care” and “custodial care.” When someone experiences confusion and struggles with basic activities of daily life — getting dressed, eating or taking medications — it turns into an undertaking that consumes another person’s entire day. Calling the work “custodial” does not make it “optional,” but simply abdicates the responsibility from Medicare and puts it on the family caregiver.

Through my grandfather’s final years living with dementia, I saw the toll that caregiving took on my mother, creating enormous strain and ultimately leading her to leave the workforce to handle his care. Years later, I ended up in a similar position as my wife’s primary caregiver through her cancer battle, and left behind my career to handle her care. These experiences woke me up to the struggles millions of American family caregivers face and led me to shift my life’s work to supporting caregivers.

I now lead an organization that helps families find affordable care, and I work on innovation research to support family caregivers, including an NIH-funded nationwide dementia caregiver training program. Through my work, I see the growing toll that caregiving is taking.

In a recent survey, 56% of family caregivers said they felt they had no choice in taking on the role, as the person they love would suffer if they didn’t. Men are now doing this work too — nearly two in five family caregivers are male. Research shows that 64% of family caregivers report moderate to high emotional stress, and 45% report moderate to high physical stress. These people try to sustain another’s life, while struggling to maintain their own.

Caregiving also causes long-term financial damage. A recent analysis showed that working caregivers born between 1981 and 1985 would lose $120,500 in lifetime earnings from being a caregiver — a combination of foregone earnings, losses in workplace retirement income and Social Security. Helping parents in their old age leaves you less secure.

Our society’s answer to these struggles is platitudes like “practice self-care,” but that assumes someone else can watch their father for a few hours so they can take a break.

So yes, the “SNL” skit was funny, and brothers across America should do their share. The bigger takeaway is that daughters and sons can’t indefinitely substitute for a properly functioning elder care system.

Congress should establish a defined Medicare benefit for personal-care support and especially respite care for people with dementia. Eligibility should reflect functional needs, with enough assistance to give family caregivers an occasional break. Yes, this would require public money, and we can debate that alongside the real costs millions of families are already carrying.

Older Americans deserve proper care at home that doesn’t solely require the sacrifice of their daughters and sons. The next time Washington honors family caregiving, it should name what is being sacrificed: someone else’s health, someone else’s career and someone else’s retirement.

Neal K. Shah is a healthcare researcher specializing in caregiving, workforce innovation and artificial intelligence. He wrote this for InsideSources.com. Please submit comments at yourvalley.net/letters or email them to azopinions@iniusa.org. We are committed to publishing a wide variety of reader opinions, as long as they meet our Civility Guidelines.

“Saturday Night Live”, John Mulaney, sister, freeloader, America’s healthcare system, caregivers, unpaid family caregivers, care givers, National Family Caregivers Month, Medicare, skilled care, custodial care, older Americans, dementia, family, strain, affordable care, Congress, personal-care support, respite, elder care

Share with others


Have an opinion on this story? Click here to send a letter to our editors.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here