Log in
Opinion

Valley attorney examines impact of homeowners’ association ruling

Arizona Supreme Court affirmed HOA authority to sue builders for warranty claims, but what does that mean for organizations, homeowners and builders?

Posted

OPINION — When significant construction defects are discovered in a planned community, homeowners often wonder who may sue the builder for repairs. Individual homeowners may have claims, but what happens when the alleged defects affect multiple homes, building exteriors, roofs or other components that the homeowners’ association is responsible for maintaining?

The Arizona Supreme Court addressed that issue in its July 29 decision in Gallery Community Association v. K. Hovnanian at Gallery, LLC.

The Court held that the state’s Homeowners’ Association Dwelling Actions statutes permit an HOA to pursue a claim that mirrors the implied warranty of workmanship and habitability, even if the HOA does not own the affected homes and does not have a direct contract with the builder.

The case involved an 18-unit residential community in Scottsdale. Although individual homeowners owned their homes, the HOA was responsible for maintaining certain exterior portions of the buildings, including roofs and exterior walls. After alleging that construction defects existed in both common areas and portions of the residential buildings, the HOA sued the developer.

The trial court dismissed the HOA’s warranty claims, concluding that the claims belonged to the homeowners because the HOA did not own the residential units. The Arizona Supreme Court disagreed.

The court ruled that the dwelling actions statutes authorize homeowners’ associations to bring certain construction-defect claims after complying with statutory procedures. The court concluded that responsibility for maintaining portions of residential structures, combined with the language of the statutes, allowed the HOA to pursue the action even though it did not own the individual homes.

The decision may have significant practical implications for Arizona communities.

For HOA boards, the ruling may provide a more centralized method of addressing alleged construction defects affecting multiple homes or building exteriors. Instead of requiring numerous homeowners to pursue separate claims, an HOA may be able to address certain issues through a single action.

For homeowners, the decision could affect repair responsibilities, special assessments and the timing of defect investigations. Construction-defect disputes can involve substantial costs, and an HOA’s decision to pursue litigation may have financial consequences for the community while the dispute is pending.

Buyers, sellers and real estate professionals should also be aware that pending construction-defect investigations or lawsuits can affect property transactions. Issues involving alleged defects, repair obligations or related litigation may influence property values, disclosure considerations, financing and marketability.

Builders and developers may face increased exposure to HOA-led construction-defect litigation involving residential units that the HOA does not own. The long-term impact of the ruling remains to be seen, but the decision could influence future risk-management practices, repair negotiations, insurance issues and construction-defect litigation throughout Arizona.

Importantly, the Supreme Court did not determine that the builder was liable for any defects. The court addressed only whether the HOA was legally authorized to pursue the claim. The allegations themselves must still be proven in the trial court.

In addition, HOAs must continue to comply with applicable statutory requirements before filing suit, including notice and right-to-repair procedures and other legal prerequisites. Governing documents, limitation periods, available defenses and the specific facts of each case remain critical.

The central takeaway is straightforward: Under Arizona law, HOA ownership of residential units is no longer an automatic requirement for an HOA to pursue a construction-defect claim that mirrors the implied warranty of workmanship and habitability. However, obtaining authority to file a lawsuit is only the first step. Whether a claim succeeds will continue to depend on the facts, evidence, governing documents and applicable law.

Benjamin L. Gottlieb is founding partner of a Chandler-based law firm and is an Arizona Department of Real Estate-approved instructor who teaches continuing-education courses to Realtors. This op-ed is for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Please submit comments at yourvalley.net/letters or email them to AzOpinions@iniusa.org. We are committed to publishing a wide variety of reader opinions, as long as they meet our Civility Guidelines.

Arizona, construction defects, planned community, multiple homes, building exteriors, roofs, homeowners association maintains, warranty claims, Arizona Supreme Court, Gallery Community Association v. K. Hovnanian at Gallery, LLC, Homeowners’ Association Dwelling Actions, builders

Share with others


Have an opinion on this story? Click here to send a letter to our editors.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here