Reader speaks out on upcoming golfing foursomes trial
This opinion is in response to Harry Emerson of the Golf Advisory Committee published in the May 28, 2025 Independent.
While I support the potential change to foursomes and the elimination of fivesomes, I don’t believe the implementation of this “trial” has adequately taken into consideration the existing fivesomes and who of the group will get the “short straw” and sit at home. Possibly, phasing in the system for those long time fivesomes would be fairer instead of the actual inadequate notification given golfers.
Mr. Emerson also blames the longer pace of play on the failed lottery system and how it may be manipulated by golfers to avoid sharing carts. Maybe, but there is also a strong possibility that the three-cart maximum rule itself is to blame since it forces golfers sharing a cart to take extra time driving back and forth between their golf shots (and increasing wear on the golf course). Golfers do seem inclined to organize and play more in threesomes and foursomes to minimize having to share carts.
You must be a member to read this story.
Join our family of readers starting at $5 for your first month and support local, unbiased journalism.
Click here to see your options for becoming a subscriber.
Register to comment
Click here create a free account for posting comments.
Note that free accounts do not include access to premium content on this site.
I am anchor
OPINIONS
Reader speaks out on upcoming golfing foursomes trial
Posted
By Mark Littau | Sun City
This opinion is in response to Harry Emerson of the Golf Advisory Committee published in the May 28, 2025 Independent.
While I support the potential change to foursomes and the elimination of fivesomes, I don’t believe the implementation of this “trial” has adequately taken into consideration the existing fivesomes and who of the group will get the “short straw” and sit at home. Possibly, phasing in the system for those long time fivesomes would be fairer instead of the actual inadequate notification given golfers.
Mr. Emerson also blames the longer pace of play on the failed lottery system and how it may be manipulated by golfers to avoid sharing carts. Maybe, but there is also a strong possibility that the three-cart maximum rule itself is to blame since it forces golfers sharing a cart to take extra time driving back and forth between their golf shots (and increasing wear on the golf course). Golfers do seem inclined to organize and play more in threesomes and foursomes to minimize having to share carts.
The ACTUAL manipulation of the lottery system is being done by those running it to the advantage of the “small groups” that are given preferred tee times without having to enter the lottery.
The fact is that some members of the Board and the Golf Advisory Committee do not consider golfer input in their decision-making process and also fail to realize that the three-cart rule is universally disliked by the golfing community and is thought to be ineffective as well as inconvenient by most golfers.
The USGA pamphlet that the decision was and still is based on basically says: three carts less than five, so that good. I understand that the USGA will not be invited back this year to review the course conditions as in the past. This might have been a great opportunity for them to review the ACTUAL condition of the courses in the year plus since the three-cart rule has been in effect and judge if it has been effective or not especially at the specific actual locations initially documented to justify the three-cart rule. This is something that the Board member(s) and the Golf Advisory Committee apparently have not been inclined to pursue.
Additionally, If the Golf Advisory Committee would like to have comments from golfers according to Mr. Emerson, perhaps they should structure their meetings to get appropriate guest input DURING discussions instead of asking if any golfers have comments after the issue is discussed and voted on as I experienced.
Please send your comments to AzOpinions@iniusa.org. We are committed to publishing a wide variety of reader opinions, as long as they meet our Civility Guidelines.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here