Log in
Education

Why families choose Litchfield schools and what makes them stay

Posted

Academic programs and reputation may bring families to the Litchfield Elementary School District, but relationships with teachers, staff and school communities appear to play a greater role in keeping them there.

That distinction emerged from an analysis of thousands of open enrollment applications, family surveys and school community discussions presented to the district's governing board during a Nov. 17 meeting.

The findings are helping district leaders develop a new educational promise intended to guide decisions about staffing, academic programs and future investments.

Chief Financial Officer Michael Vaughn and district administrators examined 6,418 open enrollment application records spanning the 2025-26 and 2026-27 school years, along with feedback from all 15 regular district schools and surveys of families who left.

Among 595 applications from prospective students living outside the district, 37% cited Litchfield’s reputation or recommendations from others as reasons for applying, while 28% pointed to academic quality, programs and educational opportunities.

For continuing families, the priorities were different.

Among 3,810 continuing application records, 28% mentioned a positive school experience or good fit, 22% emphasized community and belonging and 15% cited relationships with trusted staff. Academic programs and opportunities also appeared in 15% of the responses.

Board member Kimberly Moran questioned why academic quality appeared less frequently among returning families.

“Do you think that's because academic quality is our standard and that's just a given in our district?” Moran asked. “Do you think parents actually value relationships over academics, or is there something else?”

Vaughn said families may initially choose Litchfield because of its academic reputation but develop additional reasons to stay once their children are enrolled.

“They've already come to us for the academics, and they're staying with us because we're both giving them those academics, but they're in the community and tied in with the relationships,” Vaughn said.

The distinction could influence how the district allocates resources as administrators consider additional investments following an improved financial forecast.

Moran cautioned against interpreting the findings to mean academics should receive less attention simply because families mentioned relationships more often.

She also urged district leaders to consider whether individual campuses need additional support to deliver a consistent experiences for those that attend.

The analysis found that among 367 new out-of-district applications identifying a positive attraction, 78% referenced an individual school while 26% mentioned the district. Some applications referenced both.

Those findings underscore the importance of individual campus performance and reputation, Moran said.

The district also examined survey responses from families who left Litchfield schools.

Among respondents who moved outside the district, 80% rated their previous Litchfield experience positively. Among those who left without moving, that figure was 46%.

For families who had not moved, proximity and the variety of learning options were each cited by 46% as reasons for choosing another school, followed by teachers at 44% and safety at 33%.

The findings suggest that maintaining strong relationships may be important in a school choice environment where families have multiple options.

Board member Michele Wallace said the feedback highlighted  contributions of employees throughout the district, not just classroom teachers.

“They're connected to their principals, their teachers, the support staff, the people that are working in our food services, their bus drivers,” Wallace said.

She said maintaining the district's culture and supporting employees should remain priorities.

Superintendent Carter Davidson described the proposed educational promise as an effort to ensure students are known, valued, cared for and challenged.

The proposed statement emphasizes supportive relationships, partnerships with families, high academic expectations and opportunities for students to take initiative in their learning.

District officials said the statement is intended to guide decisions about what programs and services to strengthen, protect or reconsider.

Retaining employees would be essential to fulfilling those commitments, Moran said.

“I really hope that we can pour more into retaining the people that we have, and of course attracting more of those like-minded people,” she said.

The discussion comes as Litchfield projects approximately $3.7 million to $4 million more in annual operating revenue than expenditures over the next several years, creating opportunities for additional investments in schools and employees.

Administrators expect to present recommendations for additional spending in December.

The governing board did not vote on the proposed educational promise Nov. 17. District officials intend to bring it back for formal consideration at a future meeting.

Editor’s note:   A grant from the Arizona Local News Foundation made this story possible. The foundation awarded 15 newsrooms to pay for solutions-focused education reporters for two years. Please submit comments at yourvalley.net/letters or email them to AzOpinions@iniusa.org. We are committed to publishing a wide variety of reader opinions, as long as they meet our Civility Guidelines.

LESD79, Board meeting

Share with others


Have an opinion on this story? Click here to send a letter to our editors.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here