A request to rezone an almost 2-acre site in District 2 near the northwest corner of East Brown and North Greenfield roads for a multifamily development was introduced during the Mesa City Council meeting Monday.
The council unanimously voted to move the request for the rezone, as well as site plan approval, to its Dec. 8 meeting for possible final action.
Before the vote, almost a dozen residents voiced their opposition to the 1.9-acre “Greenfield Project” that calls for five buildings ranging from two to three stories with a total of 30-units running along the Roosevelt Water Conservation District canal. The developers did not speak during the meeting.
Residents are citing concerns with privacy, increased traffic on Greenfield Road and too many apartment units for the size of the site.
The project’s owner, Johnstar LLC, is asking that the site be rezoned from single residence to multi-residence.
“Per the Mesa 2040 General Plan, (multi-residence rezoning) is a secondary zoning district, and multiple residence is a primary land use in the neighborhood suburban character area,” a staff report stated. “A majority of the surrounding area has already developed or is zoned for primary land uses or zoning districts, and the character and form of the proposed development is consistent with the neighborhood suburban character area.”
The residents who spoke out disagreed.
“Rezoning this parcel … isn’t just a minor adjustment. It is an extreme shift from one unit per lot to roughly 15 units per lot,” Kaye F. Hunsaker told the council. “There are no other three-story structures nearby, and those upper story windows will look directly into backyards and homes, destroying privacy. This case has been dragging on since 2021. Its history alone is a major red flag.”
On Sept. 23, the city’s Planning and Zoning Board voted 4-3 to recommend the project’s approval with conditions.
Some of those conditions were installing off-site improvements, pedestrian walkways, making additional material or architectural elements and providing a mural on a cement block wall facing the project’s swimming pool.
“The developer’s selling points show just how cramped and lacking this project is. A pool, a dog park that has a shared wall with the pet resort next door and a painted mural. When a mural is a primary selling point, it tells you the project lacks real substance,” Hunsaker said.
At the planning meeting on Sept. 23, some residents voiced concerns about the project being near Falcon Field Airport, “citing recent and local aircraft movements, crashes and potential municipal liability issues from placing higher-density housing under flight pathways,” the report stated.
Resident Laura Lee also cited Falcon Field as a concern, not just for safety but also for future economic development.
“How we develop this piece of land will impact that Falcon Field Airport and its growth and its economic impact,” Lee said during the council meeting. “We also need to prioritize jobs and the economic growth in this area, and high-density apartments can create housing, but they also consume land that could be used for other purposes that could generate jobs and help our businesses for decades.”
District 2 Councilmember Dorean Taylor said during a Nov. 12 study session that she could not support the project because some of the buildings would be three stories tall and she thought it was too many apartment units for a 1.9-acre site. She reiterated her position at the council meeting.
“I’ve done my due diligence as a council member representing my people, and I believe that they are in the right that this is not a good fit for this piece of property, and it feels very much like it’s an asking for forgiveness instead of an asking for permission situation (by the developers),” Taylor said. “I do not appreciate that type of building there.”
She added that there are five rental communities located within 1.5 miles of the proposed Greenfield Project.
Janet Perez can be reached at jperez@iniusa.org. Please send your comments about this article to AzOpinions@iniusa.org. We are committed to publishing a wide variety of reader opinions, as long as they meet our Civility Guidelines.
Janet Perez News Editor | Queen Creek &
San Tan Valley
Meet Janet Janet Perez joined Independent Newsmedia as editor of the Queen Creek Independent and Florence Independent in 2020. She started her career in 1989 with the Gannett-owned El Paso Times. In 1992, she moved to Tempe and has worked in newspapers, magazines, radio and television. She left Arizona for three years to work at New Mexico State University and Baylor University before returning to work at Arizona State University. Missing the business, she went back to journalism in 2017.
Community: A long-time pet owner, she supports animal welfare causes.
Education: University of Texas at El Paso with a BA in journalism and a minor in political science.
Random Fact: She had a head full of random facts.
Hobbies: Reading, watching documentaries, cooking and playing with her dogs.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here