OPINION — Arizona needs to stop pretending growth and water scarcity are separate conversations. They are the same conversation. Every new subdivision, business park and resident needs the one thing the desert cannot manufacture: water.
The growth machine offers a comforting slogan: “Arizona is not running out of water. We are running out of cheap water.” That is like standing in front of an empty refrigerator and saying, “Relax. We just need to buy the expensive food.”
For decades, the Southwest treated the Colorado River like a bank account with guaranteed deposits. We kept withdrawing while the deposits shrank. Now the river is forcing a financial reckoning.
Rio Verde Foothills was Arizona’s warning.
Residents depended on hauled water filled at Scottsdale’s standpipe. When worsening Colorado River conditions triggered Scottsdale’s drought plan, that connection was severed. A shortage measured in reservoir elevations suddenly reached neighborhood driveways.
The lesson should have been obvious: water planning must come before growth planning.
Phoenix deserves credit for using water more efficiently. But efficiency does not repeal arithmetic. A more efficient house still needs water. Millions of additional residents still require additional supply.
Agriculture deserves scrutiny too, especially thirsty crops grown for export. But turning farms into subdivisions is not automatically progress. Water insecurity should not become food insecurity.
For a century, Arizona asked, “How much water can we find for the growth we want?”
We should be asking, “How much growth can the water actually support?”
That is not anti-growth. It is sustainability, and sustainability is real prosperity.
You cannot keep adding straws to a glass that is getting smaller.
The Colorado River does not attend ribbon cuttings, read economic forecasts or care about slogans. It delivers what nature provides. The river gets the last word.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here