Getting more transit options in the Sun Cities and other areas of the West Valley is a matter of funding, an aspect of the issue that puts unincorporated areas at a disadvantage.
Because cities and towns are incorporated and have councils, mayors and support staff, they have advocates available to help secure funding and other ways to bring in transit. Cities and towns also have the funding, whereas unincorporated areas like the Sun Cities have no such governmental structure.
Getting more transit options in the Sun Cities and other areas of the West Valley is a matter of funding, an aspect of the issue that puts unincorporated areas at a disadvantage.
Because cities and towns are incorporated and have councils, mayors and support staff, they have advocates available to help secure funding and other ways to bring in transit. Cities and towns also have the funding, whereas unincorporated areas like the Sun Cities have no such governmental structure.
“We don’t have the clout cities and towns do,” said Bonnie Boyce-Wilson, Northwest Valley Connect board member.
She and Sharon Hettick, another NVC board member, are working to get more transit options for the Sun Cities. But so far they have been unsuccessful.
“It’s just an uphill battle,” Ms. Hettick said.
One example of city clout the Sun Cities don’t have was in 2019 when Valley Metro officials planned changes to the Paratransit program that would limit ridership. Surprise officials were able to sign an intergovernmental agreement with Valley Metro that kept full Dial-A-Ride services in the city.
“Through our IGA with Valley Metro, we opt to select the services we want to provide our residents,” Dave Kohlbeck, Surprise public assistant public works director, said in July 2019. “The master agreement is good for seven years. Each year, we renew the services we want to provide. When we renewed in June this fiscal year, we kept the four services that we had last year.”
Valley Metro officials spent $65,000 on a transit survey for the Northwest Valley and results will be presented and discussed during a public meeting 10 a.m. Tuesday, March 17 in the social hall at R.H. Johnson Recreation Center, 19803 R.H. Johnson Blvd., Sun City West.
Sun Citians have two options to give them the clout they lack, but neither option — incorporation and forming a taxing district — would not be popular.
“One of the reasons people move to the Sun Cities or unincorporated areas is the lower tax base,” Scott Isham, Maricopa County District 4 Supervisor Clint Hickman’s chief of staff, stated in an email. “With that comes less government services.”
It is similar to how unincorporated households deal with fire coverage, trash pickup, sewer and water, he added.
“Communities could form a transit taxing district to cover their transit needs,” Mr. Isham stated.
Both Sun City and Sun City West flirted with incorporation in their early years. But a long drawn out battle did not end until the 1990s, long after a formal vote to incorporate failed. Sun City voters, with nearly a 100% turnout, voted in 1964 on an incorporation proposal for a mayor-city council plan, according to Sun City resident Ben Roloff.
“Incorporation supporters were disappointed when only 28% approved the mayor-city council plan,” he stated in an email.
That 1964 election was the only formal vote on incorporation ever conducted in Sun City, though the topic remained a front-burner issue for another two decades.
“That battle in the later years included efforts to include Sun City West and they were conducting meetings at the Sun Dome discussing the pros and cons,” Sun City resident Bill Pearson stated in an email.
Incorporation proponents focused on revenue sharing that was initially about $2 million but by the mid-1980s they were claiming $6 million-$8 million of lost revenue per year, according to Mr. Pearson. Revenue sharing would be used to create an internal structure of elected city officials and accompanying city services.
“The claim was there would always be money left over and all we would be doing was spending the tax dollars we were paying but not getting back,” he stated.
Transportation was one of those areas proponents said incorporation would deal with.
The various opposition organizations created over the years asked why Sun Cities residents would want to change the unique system/structure built within their communities.
“They asked, ‘Why would we risk becoming just another city when our original concept was working so well?’” Mr. Pesrson stated.
Formation of special taxing districts are governed by state statutes ARS 48-261 and ARS 48-263(A)(1). In addition, ARS 48-902 is the section prescribing the authorization for an improvement district, according to Mr. Isham.
“This would be an avenue the residents could go if they want to tax themselves,” Mr. Isham stated. “I’m not entirely sure what the residents want and to what level of service, so it may need the legislature to make tweaks to accomplish their goal.”
ARS 48-902 also allows the board of directors of an improvement district to contract for or in any other manner provide transportation services within the district, according to Mr. Isham.
County officials believe they are fulfilling their mandate regarding public transportation.
“Maricopa County is an arm of state government and as such is tasked with our statutory mandates,” Mr. Isham explained. “The county is mandated to provide paratransit (Dial-A-Ride) services in the Americans with Disabilities Act mandated areas within unincorporated Maricopa County.
Paratransit provides transportation for ADA qualified riders within three-quarters of a mile of bus routes. The county provides supplemental funding of $1.2 million to support the ADA mandated areas and also to have RideChoice (Lyft, private taxis/vans) for those who are ADA certified throughout unincorporated areas of Maricopa County, according to Mr. Isham.
However, there is only one bus route in Sun City — Peoria Avenue to 111th Avenue to Thunderbird Boulevard and back again. That leaves a vast majority of residents without transit services, according to Ms. Hettick.
“There are a lot of people not within that ADA restriction, who are also not ADA qualified, who are in dire need of transportation,” she added.
Maricopa County also officials argue Sun Cities residents are not completely without transit services.
“Now besides Dial-A-Ride, non ADA residents now have Uber and Lyft to supplement their transportation needs,” Mr. Isham stated.
Uber and Lyft are private ride-sharing companies that operate similar to a taxi.
Residents also have the services of Northwest Valley Connect, an agency started in 2014 through a partnership between Benevilla and Sun Health, designed to help residents find transit options. NVC staff and volunteers do so by recommending the few transit agencies that do exist, taxis and rides through its own programs.
But Sun City West resident Larry Woods believes the agency has some flaws.
“I personally don’t think they have a good definition as to what they are,” he stated in an email. “I hear ‘bus,’ then ‘taxi.’ Then I hear ‘Sun City West’ and then ‘West Valley.’ It seems as if, depending on the day, they are wearing a different hat.”
Regarding extended bus routes and other transit options, Mr. Woods agrees the Sun Cities are handicapped because they are not incorporated.
“The money is controlled by Maricopa Association of Governments, and Sun City West ain’t part of it,” he stated.
An organization called Sun Cities Area Transit once handled the Dial-A-Ride services in Sun City since 1982. The agency offered transportation to Sun City, Sun City West and Youngtown residents with up to 14 vehicles.
However, by 2010 SCAT was facing difficult financial times due to dwindling funding sources. The agency could not survive on paid ridership alone and received funding from Valley Metro to operate the Dial-A-Ride program. But the valley-wide public transit agency changed the way it handled the DAL funds, which would potentially take up to $175,000 from the SCAT budget, according to Pete Davis, then SCAT board secretary. When that plan was proposed, SCAT officials took some cost-cutting measures, including terminating the paid executive director and cutting its 14 employees’ wages by 25%.
The Sun City agency did see an upswing in riders during the summer of 2010, according to Tom Profico, a former SCAT board president who was serving as acting executive director with minimal pay in late-2010.
SCAT was also receiving funds from Valley of the Sun United Way, but required their funded partners have a paid executive director in place, according to Judy Beeson, then SCAT board president.
SCAT officials looked for alternative funding sources, including grants, vehicle sponsors and advertising on the side of agency vehicles.
However, SCAT officials announced in December 2010 the agency was ending operations. The move coincided with Valley Metro’s Regional Public Transportation Authority switching Dial-A-Ride funds from SCAT to Total Transit beginning Dec. 31, 2010.
In Sun City West, the Foundation there operated buses within the community for a number of years. But the service was ended in 2017 as the Foundation board handed over those services to Northwest Valley Connect and Valley Metro.
Sun City West Foundation officials started bus service in 2008 at a time when SCAT began facing its financial difficulties. Foundation officials eventually purchased SCAT buses when that agency ended operations. The Foundation committed significant financial resources exceeding $80,000 annually, according to a February 2017 press release announcing the end of service.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here