What’s behind America’s ‘blue tsunami?’

Ben Olinsky: Americans rejected MAGA’s broken promises

OPINION — Since August, President Trump told voters in places like Texas, Georgia, Ohio and South Carolina to vote as if he were on the ballot. They did. 

On Nov. 3, their message was unequivocal: It’s time for change. States that haven’t sent a Democrat to the Senate in 90 years voted to do so. Texas finally went blue. Voters turned out in huge numbers because their families are struggling to make ends meet, repudiate corruption and check a president who has gone too far.

They cast their votes to hold Donald Trump and Republicans accountable for having total control of Washington but making their lives worse off.

Exit polls confirm voters were driven by the high costs of gas, food and utilities — blaming Trump’s tariffs, cuts to healthcare, and his baseless war with Iran. Trump’s broken promises to lower prices echoed against his focus on oil company profits and vanity projects. 

Corruption also dominated voters’ concerns across party lines, as Americans see politicians getting richer while in office through insider trading and self-dealing.

It’s been impossible not to see taxpayer money go to Trump-linked firms, pardons for sale, and government funds held hostage for political reasons. Americans increasingly understand that corruption directly affects their pocketbooks.

Many voters were concerned about the immigration crackdown that has torn so many families apart and resulted in American citizens being shot dead by federal agents.

The coalition that helped hand Trump a victory in 2024 came apart, with Latinos, Black men, and young voters shifting back toward Democrats. These voters helped fuel wins by Democrats in House races across the South, including in Texas and Florida, where Republicans redrew districts at Trump’s direction. Those efforts to subvert voters’ will through unprecedented gerrymandering largely backfired.

Americans also rejected billionaires’ attempts to buy elections via extreme spending. Elon Musk alone spent nearly half a billion dollars to drown out voters’ voices. Most of the $168 million he gave to the Senate Leadership Fund was used to boost Republican Ken Paxton in Texas. Musk didn’t succeed this time, but no billionaire or corporation should decide who represents us. 

Ruby red Montana, with a long history of combating money in politics, led the way and voted overwhelmingly to pass a ballot initiative that removes corporations’ state-granted power to spend money in politics.

Montana joins Hawaii, where a similar law passed nearly unanimously earlier this year — and together, this momentum paves the way for citizens in other states to do the same.

We also learned that Americans do, in fact, care about character and civility. Democratic candidates like Adam Hamilton in Kansas and James Talarico in Texas won their bids to join the Senate by imbuing their campaigns with moral messages rooted in their faiths. Others like Abdul El-Sayed stood fast under vile attacks on their religion. 

Americans rejected hate, sending a message that it’s time to rebuild the bonds between us. America has aspired to a radical idea that it doesn’t matter where you’ve come from or how you pray, only that you buy into a democratic government in which people hold the power, not a king.

This year’s elections stood as a testament to the thousands of brave state and local election workers who did their jobs with little fanfare. They upheld the law, even in the face of vile threats of prosecution from the Trump administration, ensuring our elections remain some of the best-run in the world. Every vote will be counted, winners will be certified and seated, and we will look back on a free and fair election.

For congressional Republicans, Tuesday night’s results should be evidence that Donald Trump is a losing proposition. His time shaping our political landscape is coming to an end. It was his policies, broken promises, crassness and incompetence that left Republicans routed.

The party now has a choice to stand up to the president and work with Democrats to deliver on the policies Americans are demanding, or else drown with a sinking ship.

Democrats would be wise to remember that Trump was on the ballot this year; next time they will be judged. They must act aggressively to put ordinary families first, lower costs, hold the administration accountable, and root out corruption. Votes are rented, not owned, and elected leaders must show they’re truly willing to put Americans first.

Ben Olinsky is the senior vice president for structural reform and governance policy at the Center for American Progress Action Fund. He wrote this for InsideSources.com. 

Tell Us What You Think

What are your thoughts on the outcome of the 2026 midterms and why Americans voted they way they did? Tell us in 300 words or less at yourvalley.net/letters, or email your comments, name, street address and contact number to azopinions@iniusa.org.

Jared Whitley: Republicans bet on big-government policies — and lost

OPINION — After a big loss, there’s always plenty of finger-pointing. Well, get ready because I have eight fingers (and two thumbs) to point.

Republicans who borrowed big-government ideas from the left paid for it Nov. 3. Voters wanted lower costs and an honest government, and conservatives have the better plan for both.

In 1960, Barry Goldwater wrote that he had “little interest in streamlining government or in making it more efficient, for I mean to reduce its size.” Ronald Reagan carried that message successfully to 44 states in 1980 and 49 in 1984.

Principled conservatism wins, and that broad conservative majority still exists.

Republicans who lost on Tuesday deviated from principled conservatism and adopted populism as their calling card. Unfortunately, populism usually leads to a larger government, which leads to corruption.

Corruption was the surprise issue of this campaign. In a Fox News poll last month, 88% of voters said they were extremely or very concerned about corruption in government, edging out inflation.

Corruption grows when Washington has more favors to hand out. Every mandate, subsidy and price control creates a lobby to protect it. The surest way to shrink corruption is to shrink the government.

Americans want lower gas prices. But big government regulations such as the Renewable Fuel Standard help make gas more expensive for Americans — a key aspect of affordability. In fact, the price of regular gas averaged $4.22 a gallon right before the election, according to AAA, up from $2.83 when the year began.

The RFS forces refiners to blend ethanol and other biofuels into gasoline and diesel. The Institute for Energy Research estimates that the mandate adds 37 cents to every gallon, twice the federal gas tax. Taxpayers then pay again through federal tax credits for ethanol and other biofuels.

Another way to get government out of the way is to eliminate permitting barriers. Minnesota regulators issued permits for the NorthMet copper-nickel mine in 2018. Courts and federal regulators then revoked or sent back three of its major permits. Eight years later, the mine has not produced a single ton of ore.

Valero blamed the state’s rules when it shut down its Benicia, California, plant in April. The last major new refinery in America opened in 1977. Congress should protect the refineries we have and make it easier to build new ones, starting with the Senate’s bipartisan permitting bill.

Policies like these will increase affordability and help Republicans win in future elections.

Big Government proposals such as data center moratoriums and so-called surveillance pricing may be popular in the short term, but neither idea would cut a single family’s bills.

Republicans should let the market work. Prices fall when sellers compete for customers and new suppliers can enter the market. Data center moratoriums block new investment, and pricing bans tell businesses what they may charge. Broad surveillance pricing proposals would deprive consumers of loyalty discounts and promotions. Both put government where competition should be.

Another prime example of Republicans wrongly embracing government is in Kansas. The state has not elected a Democrat to the Senate since 1932. Republican Sen. Roger Marshall won his first race there by 11 points in 2020. On Tuesday, he lost to Democrat Adam Hamilton.

The outcome in Kansas could have been avoided if Marshall had stuck to the conservative principles of limited government and free markets. Instead, Marshall tied his senatorial career to expanding government power by sponsoring the deceptively named Credit Card Competition Act.

The bill is a liberal’s dream — an expansion of the Federal Reserve’s power over credit card payments. If enacted, the Fed could dictate how consumers use their credit cards in stores or online. Instead of creating competition, the bill eliminates consumer choice and puts credit card rewards programs, essentially massive discounts, at risk. Lobbyists in Washington may care deeply about this issue; based on Election Day, Kansans clearly don’t.

Populists in the Republican Party argue that, in certain cases, it is justified to use government for their own purposes, just as Democrats do. While there may be truth to that, as a rule, the Democrats’ mantra of more bread and circuses is no panacea for the affordability crisis millions of Americans are facing today. Tuesday’s election outcomes make that clear.

Using the federal government to suppress competition through price controls and investment moratoriums will ultimately do nothing to make life more affordable for Americans. These may seem like simple solutions, but their grievous mistake is that they will limit economic growth while making things more expensive for all Americans.

Instead of making life more affordable, populists may have inadvertently taken options away from Americans and, with them, the individual freedom to use their credit cards when and where they want.

Republicans can and should start in the lame-duck session by getting back to basics — less government regulation and more free markets. Loosening onerous permitting restrictions and cutting regulations on American energy production by eliminating the RFS are good places to start. At the same time, Republicans need to avoid populist proposals that would cripple the economy. That agenda delivers the lower costs and honest government voters demanded.

Jared Whitley has worked in the Senate, the Bush White House and the military industry. He wrote this for InsideSources.com.