Questions remain on travel order in Arizona

Posted 4/8/20

PHOENIX — Have friends flying in from Fort Worth? Roanoke Va.? Or even Lesterville, S.D.?

Well, they may not be able to come to your house to visit.

They live in areas identified as …

To Our Valued Readers –

Visitors to our website will be limited to five stories per month unless they opt to subscribe.

For $5.99, less than 20 cents a day, subscribers will receive unlimited access to the website, including access to our Daily Independent e-edition, which features Arizona-specific journalism and items you can’t find in our community print products, such as weather reports, comics, crossword puzzles, advice columns and so much more six days a week.

Our commitment to balanced, fair reporting and local coverage provides insight and perspective not found anywhere else.

Your financial commitment will help to preserve the kind of honest journalism produced by our reporters and editors. We trust you agree that independent journalism is an essential component of our democracy. Please click here to subscribe.

Charlene Bisson, Publisher, Independent Newsmedia

Please log in to continue

Log in
I am anchor

Questions remain on travel order in Arizona


PHOENIX — Have friends flying in from Fort Worth? Roanoke Va.? Or even Lesterville, S.D.?

Well, they may not be able to come to your house to visit.

They live in areas identified as having “substantial community spread” of COVID-19. And that means that, effective at 12:01 a.m. Thursday, they are subject to a new order by Gov. Doug Ducey to self-quarantine for 14 days after they arrive.

You can, however, probably go golfing with them if that’s what you enjoy.

Mr. Ducey’s directive does allow people to leave their area of self-quarantine for “essential services.” And under an earlier gubernatorial order, that includes outdoor activities like golf.

But they can’t stay with you, as the order says those affected “shall refrain from isolating or self-quarantining with family members or friends who did not travel.”

In describing his order on Tuesday, the governor specifically mentioned anyone flying in from Connecticut, New Jersey or New York. And gubernatorial press aide Patrick Ptak said that, based on the designations of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, that means anyone from anywhere in those three states, not just those coming from the New York City area.

But Mr. Ducey’s order also says it applies to anyone from an area with “significant community spread.”

Here’s where it gets even more complex.

The CDC defines significant community spread as “large scale community transmission, health care staffing significantly impacted (and) multiple cases within communal settings.” And officials in multiple communities, like New Orleans, San Antonio and even Yankton County in South Dakota — where Lesterville is located — have said they have substantial community spread.

But other than Mr. Ducey’s mention of the tri-state area, his order does not list other specific communities. Instead it tasks the Department of Health Services to come up with a list and put it on its web site so it could be implemented overnight Wednesday.

State health officials said that web page was still being developed late Wednesday afternoon.

There are other complicating factors.

Mr. Ptak said that the controlling issue over who should self-quarantine is based not on where the person normally lives but instead on the arriving flight.

Put simply, someone from Boston flying to Arizona who connects at JFK — or even if the flight stops there — would fall under the governor’s order. But passengers on a direct flight from Boston would be free to come and go as they want, subject to Mr. Ducey’s more general stay-at-home directives that apply to everyone in Arizona.

But the situation is different for places like Tucson International Airport which has no nonstop flights from the New York area.

Mr. Ptak said the quarantine order would apply to those who boarded in New York but not anyone else who came on board at an interim stop, even if they had been sitting next to someone from the first leg of the flight.

And what of those driving to Arizona or coming by train?

“The order is focused on airports because we have the ability to reach travelers that we know are arriving from these specific states of origin,” Mr. Ptak said.

But he noted that the CDC last month advised residents of the three listed states to refrain from non-essential travel, with no reference to mode of transportation.

“We would encourage anyone traveling to Arizona from one of those states to quarantine for 14 days,” Mr. Ptak said.

And just because the state is ordering people to quarantine themselves doesn’t mean Arizona taxpayers are on the financial hook.

Mr. Ducey’s order says those affected are responsible for all costs related to the isolation or quarantine, including transportation, lodging, food, medical care and “any other expenses to sustain the person” during the period.

There are exceptions to Mr. Ducey’s order.

It does not apply to airline employees or military personnel. Also not subject to the self-quarantine order are those arriving in Arizona “in direct response to COVID-19” to aid in healthcare and public health operations, as well as essential governmental or infrastructure functions.