Time for ESA supporters to get serious about reform
There are indefensible features of Arizona's school vouchers program; if supporters don’t fix them, opponents will use them to impose more extensive limitations
OPINION — Two organizations opposed to private school vouchers — Arizona Education Association and Save Our Schools Arizona — have filed an initiative placing new restrictions and requirements on the program.
Irrespective of whether the initiative gets to the ballot, this should serve as a wake-up call for voucher supporters. Certain features of the current Empowerment Scholarship Account program are indefensible, and therefore politically unsustainable. If supporters — in whose ranks I am to be found — don’t take the lead on reform, the reform field will be vacated to opponents, whose reach will extend well beyond the indefensible features of the current program, as the proposed initiative illustrates.
In one respect, the initiative is surprisingly mild. It doesn’t reverse the 2022 legislative expansion making all students eligible for ESAs — not just those falling into certain categories, such as having a disability or attending a failing public school. Instead, it puts a cap on eligibility based upon family income. Those making more than $150,000 a year would no longer be eligible.
I oppose a cap based upon income. If the state is going to have a pool of tax money to educate children, parents who prefer to send their kids to private schools shouldn’t be excluded from the common pool, irrespective of income.
However, under such a cap, the overwhelming majority of students currently eligible for vouchers would continue to be eligible, and for the same amount for which they are currently entitled. This is a significant acceptance of private schools as part of the taxpayer-supported, school-choice educational environment in Arizona. That’s a meaningful concession.
However, the initiative would expose private schools to new, and potentially expansive, regulation and oversight from the state Board of Education and Department of Education. To be eligible to receive voucher students, private schools either would have to be accredited or administer a test — the state’s achievement tests for public school students or a national alternative. Annually, each individual school would have to register with the department and pay a registration fee. Private school teachers and other school personnel would be subject to the state’s disciplinary process for public schools.
The board would have authority to prescribe “requirements for student and site safety” for private schools, an elastic phrase without a clear limiting principle. The board would also regulate the uses private schools make of the voucher money they receive, supposedly to prevent violations of a provision in the initiative forbidding voucher monies to be used for inappropriate personal and luxury items. But those abuses are occurring among homeschoolers, not private schools.
Perhaps most troubling, the board would promulgate rules “to effectively promote financial transparency” among private schools, another elastic phrase with no limiting principle.
Moreover, the board would be exempt from the state’s legal requirements for rulemaking for the initial new regulatory framework for voucher schools.
The overwhelming majority of private schools in Arizona are religiously affiliated and have been educating students for years. The vouchers granted to their students simply pay for, or offset, the tuition to attend them. This is not where the problems and abuses of the ESA program are occurring.
There are over 60 Catholic schools in Arizona. Is it really reasonable or necessary to require the Catholic Church to register each and every school individually, and pay a registration fee for each and every one, every year? With the religiously affiliated schools, there is a mission component to the enterprise. Facilities and resources are intermingled. The state has no business rummaging through the internal finances of churches in the name of “financial transparency.” Particularly when vouchers are only used to pay or offset tuition.
There are three ESA reforms that are warranted. As noted, the abuses undermining public support for the program almost all emanate from homeschoolers, not students applying the vouchers to private school tuition. The system for homeschoolers to participate in the ESA program is fatally flawed.
Basically, parents decide what educational materials or services to purchase and apply to the department for approval. The volume of requests overwhelms the capacity of the department to process them, much less effectively police them.
Instead, the department should pre-approve materials and services, and homeschooling parents should be limited to that pre-approved list. No delay and no abuse. There should be a process to petition to add materials or services to the pre-approved list. But, except for special ed students, no individualized requests.
Homeschooling parents will really not like this, and they are an influential lobbying group within the GOP. However, they are a minority of ESA beneficiaries, and flaws and vulnerabilities in the existing system for homeschoolers threaten political support for the entire program.
While initiative supporters will try to ride public outrage over these abuses, the initiative itself doesn’t really do anything about them. It leaves the fatally flawed system in place. It just says that ESA money can’t be used for those purposes, which is already the law.
The second reform deals with unexpended balances building up in ESA accounts. There are reportedly hundreds of millions of dollars that have been accumulated over the years. While allowing some limited carryover from year to year is reasonable, permitting large accumulated surpluses is not. Funds in excess of the limited carryover should be swept and returned to the state’s general fund, whence they came.
The initiative has a really sneaky provision related to this. Accumulated balances would be swept, but not returned to the general fund. Instead, they would be deposited in the classroom site fund, and from there distributed to public schools. So, an appropriation for the ESA program gets turned into increased funding for public schools without legislative action. That’s not ESA reform. That’s a money grab.
The third reform relates to accountability. Subjecting private schools to potentially extensive regulation by the state is a step too far. However, taxpayers should have some ability to see what they are getting for their money. ESA beneficiaries should be required to take the same achievement tests the state administers to public school students, with results made public in the same manner as with public schools.
The initiative only requires testing from unaccredited schools. I suspect most Arizona private schools have an accreditation of some sort, in some instances from a religiously affiliated entity. However, the initiative is silent regarding how it will be determined which accreditation organizations to accept.
The initiative backers say they have the resources committed to get it on the 2026 ballot. I’m skeptical. Gathering the number of signatures required in the time available will be difficult irrespective of how much money is thrown at it.
However, one way or another, some time or another, ESA reform is coming. Rather than treating what was passed in 2022 as an immaculate conception, supporters should be fixing problems and political vulnerabilities rather than letting them fester.
Retired Arizona journalist Robert Robb opines about politics and public policy. Reach him at robtrobb@gmail.com. Please submit comments at yourvalley.net/letters or email them to AzOpinions@iniusa.org. We are committed to publishing a wide variety of reader opinions, as long as they meet our Civility Guidelines.
Arizona,
Arizona Education Association,
Save Our Schools Arizona,
ESA reform,
ESA vouchers,
homeschooling,
state Board of Education and Department of Education,
public schools,
private schools,
religiously affiliated schools,
school vouchers
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here