Surprise mayor, council hear about Rinchem, ICE Detention facility concerns
Posted
A discussion was held on possible hazards of the Rinchem chemical storage facility and the Immigration and Customs Enforcement warehouse during the Oct. 20 Surprise City Council meeting at City Hall.
Independent Newsmedia/Jason Stone
So the facility, no matter what the facility is, depending on who is, what is housed there or what it is, they have to evacuate their facility. We do not have the resources or the capacity. We do not have the resources or capacity to evacuate surrounding facilities.”
A presentation and discussion on possible hazards in the community blew up about the Rinchem chemical storage facility and the Immigration and Customs Enforcement warehouse, after a presentation to the Surprise City Council.
Following up to a June 16 request by Councilman Patrick Duffy, staff was asked to research and discuss the possibilities of a catastrophic event and what that would look like with a chemical storage facility within the city.
City council members heard a presentation during their Oct. 20 meeting at City Hall about the Rinchem property, dating back to 1999 when the site was annexed in to the city.
In 2020, the site was rezoned from light industrial to general industrial purposes, which allowed for more uses under the zoning district. It was approved by council as part of a larger rezoning application that required a public hearing, said Trever Fleetham, city planning manager.
Fleetham added that the site plan and reports were approved in 2022 to be in compliance for warehouse/distribution and outdoor storage. Building permits were issued, and a certificate of occupancy was granted in 2024.
“Because this was known to be a rental facility, it was designed with that in mind. So it wasn’t a warehouse facility that was being retrofitted to be able to store and distribute chemicals. It was designed and built for that specific function,” said Fleetham, noting the property remained in compliance with the 2022 city code.
The presentation included input from fire department officials, describing checks and balances done to ensure all facilities are in compliance on a local, federal, state and county level when hazardous materials are involved.
A review happens before construction and an evaluation is done on what is proposed, materials that will be present and how they will be stored to ensure it is in compliance.
Depending on the chemicals on site, fire officials would use different tactics and response levels for any emergency. Precautions to any scenario could include the city issuing orders to shelter indoors or to evacuate if there are issues. Fire alarm systems, ventilation and gas detection among safety features are reviewed in the process.
However, city officials offered no definitive answer when Duffy asked about the distance businesses should be away from facilities that will have hazardous materials, particularly as it relates to the 418,000-square-foot ICE facility set to be occupied at Sweetwater Avenue and Dysart Road across the street from Rinchem, which will contain hazardous and regulated materials.
“I mean, what they are basically trying to do is put a hotel next to a chemical facility, and that’s something we wouldn’t allow. So I guess, is there a certain amount of feet it has to be away with the evacuation rules?,” said Duffy.
Fleetham said the site plan met requirements to be adjacent to other industrial zoning districts, but noted there would be an expanded setback for residential requirements.
Duffy further questioned allowances that were based on what was approved at the time and not what is “trying to be pushed in there.”
“That changes everything, All this response, it changes it,” said Duffy, pointing out the city would not allow a residential setting 300 or 400 feet away from two buildings that could pose a risk.
Duffy also asked if the Department of Homeland Security had communicated any potential evacuation plans if there is an emergency.
“At this time, we have not received any emergency plans or how they plan to handle the facility at this time,” said Surprise City Manager Andrea Davis, adding the city had sought the plans from DHS.
Duffy said his concern was DHS should have provided those answers already considering how fast they were trying to open.
“We need some answers from them because you guys do a great job. This is not anything on you. I feel bad for Rinchem on this whole thing, too. They didn’t ask for this, and now they’re in the spotlight. And now they have to worry. We need answers on what would happen.” Duffy said.
While the workshop discussion didn’t allow for public comments, some residents made those comments at the regular meeting immediately after.
Davis noted how it is the city’s responsibility to respond to the emergency and communicate to people about evacuation plans, but they do not evacuate facilities.
“We let people know where the evacuation is needed and when and how, but everyone is responsible to self evacuate,” she said. “So the facility, no matter what the facility is, depending on who is, what is housed there or what it is, they have to evacuate their facility. We do not have the resources or the capacity. We do not have the resources or capacity to evacuate surrounding facilities.”
Mayor Kevin Sartor stated he didn’t doubt the city could handle an emergency at Rinchem if one arose, but questioned DHS for putting a facility that could have up to 1,500 people close by. At the same time, because it was a federal decision there was little the city could do.
“We have gone to D.C.,” Sartor said. “We have met them here. We have talked to every federal elected official that we can aside from the president that has control over the city of Surprise and Arizona, beating the drum of we need information, we need an emergency plan, we need any information we can get. Some have helped some have not.”
The situation is frustrating, Sartor said, because it is taking the city’s time, resources and effort for something “we didn’t even have a clue about them bringing” to the city.
Representatives from the Northwest Valley Indivisible, a grassroots progressive organization in Arizona’s 8th Congressional District, shared concerns about the Rinchem facility across the street from the planned ICE detention facility.
The organization’s research on Rinchem was cited in Arizona Attorney General Kris Mayes’s lawsuit, Arizona v. Mullin. The attorney general reportedly noted the site unsuitable for a mass detention facility because of its location in a potential chemical hazard zone.
Her lawsuit noted Rinchem’s federal risk management plan does not account for a detention facility next door. A June 30 agreement in that lawsuit paused detention and construction pending environmental review.
“Attorney General Mayes looked at the facts and took a stand. Now it’s the mayor and council’s turn,” stated Brent Peak, Northwest Valley Indivisible co-chair.
Lynne Gehling, the NWVI researcher who reviewed Rinchem’s risk management plan, said the company’s emergency planning was written before it was proposed as a place for “locking hundreds of people across the street.”
“There is no plan that makes a toxic cloud safe for people who can’t evacuate on their own,” Gehling stated.
The group detailed in a media release worse case and realistic scenarios concerning Rinchem, including accidents that can cause “a toxic cloud 2.7 miles and covers more than 73,000 people, affecting Dysart High School, which is less than a mile from the facility, and people detained in a center.
NWVI representatives brought out during the meeting said they sent city officials five emails since July 9 without a written reply, and requested additional records, with responses yet to be received from city staff or the mayor.
Delarita Ford can be reached at dford@iniusa.org. Submit comments at yourvalley.net/letters or email them to AzOpinions@iniusa.org. We are committed to publishing a wide variety of reader opinions, as long as they meet our Civility Guidelines.
Meet Delarita Delarita Ford originally joined Independent Newspapers Incorporated, now Independent Newsmedia, Inc. USA in 1997, as a general assignment reporter for the Delaware State News daily paper after starting her journalism career in Maryland in 1994, where she honed her skills by writing obituaries, covering community news from births to deaths, education to legislation and more. As a reporter, she has had the opportunity to cover sitting and former U.S. presidential visits in Baltimore, Delaware, and Arizona.
Community: One of the few seasoned journalists who still enjoys covering community events, she can be found with a reporter’s pad taking notes, her phone taking pictures while capturing life’s moments to memorialize them in print for the local newspapers and for the active-adult community where she lives. She maintains a presence with the Black media and the National Association of Black Journalists to encourage peers, socialize, and mentor younger writers.
Education: Life learner who learns from life. Aside from the collegiate education received, she got the best training from on-the-job experience with former editors who went through copy with a red pen and demanded the best writing for hard news and feature stories.
Random Fact: While a Delaware State News reporter, she could call then Sen. Joe Biden and his wife, Dr. Jill Biden, usually late at night if a quote or input was needed for varying topics, including legislation and education.
Hobbies: Adopt rescue dogs and give them a nice home. Continuously read and critique news stories from various platforms.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here