A new bill has passed the Arizona Legislature giving municipalities authority to issue licenses and permits to short-term rentals.
Senate Bill 1168, which passed the Arizona Senate and House of Representatives on June 24, is supported by both the short-term rental industry and local cities.
The bill is now in the hands of Gov. Doug Ducey to sign. According to officials at the Town of Paradise Valley, where short-term rentals are numerous, SB1168 grants cities and towns the authority to issue short-term rental licenses or permits, and within guidelines, allows suspension of those permits for up to a year.
The bill was sponsored by J.D. Mesnard, R-Chandler, and co-sponsored by Steve Kaiser, R-Phoenix.
“While the bar is very high to suspend STRs, cities and towns do not take this new authority lightly, just as we do with all of our land use permits,” said Town Manager Jill Keimach. “We anticipate that our new enforcement power to suspend will make a difference for owners and/or managers who repeatedly bring bad actors into our neighborhoods. While we can always use more tools and stronger enforcement regulations, we’re happy to have some new tools to attempt to better safeguard our community.”
Keimach says more information will be shared as the town puts a local framework into place to leverage these new tools across Paradise Valley.
Overall, Keimach says the Town Council and Paradise Valley officials understand every legislative bill is a compromise on both sides.
“We feel this is a huge step forward, a significant step forward,” Keimach said. “The change is incremental and we’re thinking that this goes a long way to add authority, permitting, enforcement to what started out as [SB]1350, which said short-term rentals can do whatever they want and we can’t respond. We don’t have all the tools we need, but we will have much more direct communication with the hosts.”
Keimach says the town is hopeful Ducey will sign the bill because it’s supported by both sides of the issue.
Short-term rentals have been a growing industry in Arizona since 2017, when a former bill, SB1350, took away nearly all local control from municipalities, which prevented communities from regulating or outlawing the vacation rental homes. In some areas of Arizona, such as Paradise Valley and Scottsdale, the short-term rentals are hotspots for group gatherings, parties and other events that neighbors find problematic.
Cities and towns will be able to permit all short-term rentals; officials say there is not currently any limit on how many short-term rental properties will be allowed, or disallowed in a municipality.
Shortly after the Arizona Legislature passed SB1168, Expedia Group — the parent company behind vacation rental platform Vrbo — released a statement supporting the bill.
“SB1168 is the result of bipartisan compromise involving local lawmakers, community leaders, neighbors, vacation rental hosts, platforms, and other stakeholders. This legislation continues to build upon the partnership between state and local authorities and the vacation rental industry by creating new mechanisms to ensure neighborhood safety while fostering an environment that will allow vacation rental hosts and their guests to continue their important contributions to a vibrant tourism economy in Arizona,” said Philip Minardi, director of policy communications at Expedia Group.
Short-term rentals in Arizona have been a growing business in recent years, despite occasional pushback from neighborhoods they are in. In a February study commissioned by Expedia Group and Airbnb, Rounds Consulting Group Inc., found short-term rental spending generated more than $500 million in state and local tax revenue from transient occupancy taxes as well as employee and business taxes.
Scottsdale resident David Mason has been an opponent of short-term rentals, including being a member on Scottsdale’s short-term rental task force. He says SB1168 is a good first step and a great effort.
“However, unfortunately, SB1168 has some serious flaws that should receive immediate attention in the 2023 session,” Mason said. “Given the magnitude of the issues and the lengthy negotiations, one would have hoped for more thoughtful drafting without some of the below flaws.”
Mason lists the licensing process as a flaw, pointing out that the owner of the property, not the property itself, is what’s licensed.
“If the owner is an LLC, all fines and suspensions can be legally evaded by simply transferring ownership of the property from LLC1 to LLC2,” Mason says.
Ultimately, Mason commends the Legislature for passing the bill.
“Importantly, it allows local governments to license short-term rentals as well as to suspend licenses, for cause, and may help reduce short-term rentals issues,” he said. “It reflects well on all parties involved the negotiation, but the parties involved did not include ordinary citizens as ‘stake holders,’ even though they are directly affected by short-term rentals.”
Marketfinder website Airdna tracks short-term rentals across the globe. In Scottsdale, Airdna reports 6,344 active rentals — most of which are entire home rentals, with only 5% of rentals being a private room.
In Paradise Valley, an additional 431 active rentals are identified, where the average daily rate is listed at $939, down from a reported $1,200 per night rate in March.
Melissa Rosequist Managing Editor | East Valley @mrosequist_
I first started my journalism portfolio at the age of 15 while in high school before going on to study at the Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communications. Being in the journalism field is the only professional avenue I was ever interested in, and have worked hard covering topics from school boards to hard news while working for the Independent, where I have been awarded for my reporting.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here