Log in
CITY GOVERNMENT

Scottsdale won’t challenge constitutionality of SB 1543 at this time

Posted

The City of Scottsdale will not challenge the constitutionality of Senate Bill 1543, known as the Axon bill, in a court of law -- at this time.

The City Council voted 4-3 to not pursue litigation right now on the matter during its Sept. 9 special meeting, according to a recording of the meeting.

Mayor Lisa Borowsky and Council Members Adam Kwasman,Maryann McAllen and Solange Whitehead voted to remove an agenda item that would have set the lawsuit in motion.

Vice Mayor Jan Dubauskas and Council Members Barry Graham and Kathy Littlefield voted to move forward with the litigation.

And now Borowsky has called a meeting at 2 p.m. Sept. 12 to “Authorize the Interim City Attorney, and/or his designees, to proceed as instructed in the executive session held on Sept. 9, 2025.”

When it came time to vote Sept. 9, Graham could be heard on a hot mic telling Littlefied how to vote, which he has done during past council meetings as well.

It wasn’t the only hot mic incident during the meeting either. Graham could also be heard telling Dubauskas, “You know, nights like this, I (expletive) hate this job, (expletive) hate it.”
Borowsky tried calling the vote before Graham had a chance to address the packed house, many of whom were Axon supporters.

“We know what it’s like not being able to speak coming from experience at our first meeting (in January),” Borowsky said.

However, when called upon, acting City Attorney Luis Santaella said Roberts Rules of Order do afford Graham the opportunity to speak before the vote.

“I am stunned and I am shocked that we are vacating this motion or withdrawing it and I see that as a vote for this apartment complex,” Graham said.

Security technology company Axon, most famous for its tasers, intends to build 1,895 apartments as part of its plan to build a new world headquarters campus in north Scottsdale near N. Hayden Road and the Loop 101.

They received a rezoning approval, allowing the apartments to go up, by the last council in November 2024 by the last council.

That sparked former city councilman Bob Littlefield (who is also Kathy Littlefield’s husband) to start a referendum on the rezoning and collected nearly 27,000 signatures to put it on the ballot.

Axon leaders asked to have the referendum as soon as possible but the new council members said they would not support an election before November 2026. That, in turn, led Axon leaders to turn to the state Legislature, which ultimately passed Senate Bill 1543, which requires cities ranging in population from 200,000 to 500,000 to allow hotels and multifamily housing in areas zoned for light industrial use without a zoning hearing as long as it is located on a property that would contain an international headquarters.

That eliminated the need for a referendum, a move opponents say negates their rights.
“Referendum is enshrined in our constitution,” Graham said. “It is a basic constitutional right that I agree with everybody who is emailing us they have the right to exercise.”

Kwasman stressed on Sept. 11 that his vote was only about the timing of the suit. The city is still in negotiations with Axon over the apartments, and he does not want to upend that with a lawsuit at this time.

“As a litigator, someone who is a civil litigator, the timing of litigation has very, very specific effects on negotiations,” Kwasman said.

Whitehead said during the meeting her vote was to protect tax dollars and voters’ rights.

“We always act judiciously so we are not going to make decisions when we don’t have full and complete information,” she said. “And I want to say that if the referendum was ever about the voice of the people, we would have already had a vote this past March.”

Borowsky said Graham’s comments “couldn’t have distorted the situation any further.”
She explained her vote, saying, “There were too many unanswered questions on the next steps, many options. I was not prepared to commit to direction and that’s it. This story is not over, unfortunately, and for now, it’s a ‘We’re not going to make a decision on this agenda item.’”

Editor's note: This story has been changed to include information about the Sept. 12 meeting.

Please send your comments to AzOpinions@iniusa.org. We are committed to publishing a wide variety of reader opinions, as long as they meet our Civility Guidelines. J. Graber can be reached at jgraber@iniusa.org.

Scottsdale, Axon, referendum, Senate Bill 1543

Share with others


Have an opinion on this story? Click here to send a letter to our editors.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here