As someone who has spent years in the dental field, I care deeply about the quality of dental care in Arizona. Recently, a bill that has been assigned a new number, Senate Bill 1448, has raised significant concerns, and I believe it’s important for everyone to understand what it could mean for our community.
SB 1448, also known as the Dentist and Dental Hygienist Compact, is designed to make it easier for dentists from other states to work in Arizona. While this sounds convenient, it could lead to some serious issues.
The bill would allow dentists to practice here without meeting all of Arizona’s specific requirements. This means that a dentist from a state with different standards could start working in Arizona without fully aligning with our local regulations. Our current rules ensure that dentists are up to date with the latest techniques and technologies, which is crucial for patient safety and quality care.
One of the primary arguments for the compact is that it will improve access to care and speed up the licensing process. However, the reality is quite different. According to the executive director of the Arizona Dental Board, it currently takes only six days to process a dental license. This is not an extended amount of time, and the compact does not offer a significant improvement in this area.
The real challenge lies in ensuring that all practicing dentists meet Arizona’s high standards, which the compact could potentially compromise. By allowing dentists to bypass specific state requirements, the compact risks lowering the quality of care available to patients.
Patient safety is a major issue. The bill lacks full reporting of disciplinary issues across state lines. This could allow dental professionals with questionable histories to practice in Arizona. Imagine a dental hygienist with a history of violations in another state easily obtaining permission to work here. Without full reporting, crucial information about past misconduct might be hidden, potentially exposing patients to substandard care or even health risks.
Proponents argue that SB 1448 will help bring dental professionals to work in Arizona from other states, however, it may have the opposite effect by making it harder to retain experienced dentists in Arizona. We might lose seasoned professionals to states with less stringent requirements, impacting the quality of dental care available to us.
For instance, a dentist nearing retirement might choose to move to a state with lower fees and fewer continuing education requirements, taking years of expertise away from our communities.
The potential impact on local control is another significant issue. Arizona’s dental board currently sets standards that meet our state’s specific needs. These standards are tailored to address the unique challenges and requirements of our communities.
However, under the new bill, we might lose some of this flexibility. This could make it more difficult to respond effectively to local needs and maintain the high standards of care that Arizonans expect and deserve.
Moreover, the bill’s implications extend beyond just the dental community. The broader public health landscape in Arizona could be affected. With the potential for reduced oversight and varying standards, the quality of dental care could become inconsistent. This inconsistency might lead to disparities in care, where some patients receive high-quality treatment while others do not. Such disparities could have long-term effects on the overall health and well-being of our population.
I encourage our representatives to vote No on SB 1448. Let’s work together to find a solution that enhances licensure processes while preserving Arizona’s authority to protect its citizens’ dental health.
The well-being of Arizonans depends on maintaining local control over our dental professional standards. By doing so, we can ensure that all Arizonans have access to the high-quality dental care they deserve.
Editor’s note: Gregory Waite, DDS, is chief of dental at San Carlos Apache Healthcare in Peridot. He lives in Mesa. Please send your comments to AzOpinions@iniusa.org. We are committed to publishing a wide variety of reader opinions, as long as they meet our Civility Guidelines.
Share with others
